What was the major outcome of the 2011 arab spring protests that took place in numerous countries?

Ten years after people rose up against their leaders in country after country around the Middle East and North Africa, from Tunisia to Egypt, Yemen and Bahrain, what can we say about how society, politics and religion have changed in the region?

To put it mildly, the social, cultural, religious, political and strategic events that history will remember as the “Arab Spring” sent a shockwave across an entire region. Today, the legacy of this chain of events is contested and to an extent still uncertain, but one thing is clear: the conditions for engaging in politics in these countries have shifted completely.

Lire cet article en français: “Révolutions arabes, an X: des sociétés à jamais transformées”

It’s true that in many places, like Egypt, we’ve seen a return to some form of the authoritarianism that reigned before the people asserted their right to take part in politics at the beginning of the 2010s. But social powers are the forces that write the definitive version of history, and these have seemingly been disrupted forever.

Citizens now know that ruling power is fragile; it can be shaky; it does not last forever. In 2021, the question is no longer whether it’s possible to topple a regime, or at least make it grant concessions, but rather what the cost-benefit analysis is for a process of political change. What price are people prepared to pay to see their situation improve?

The power of protest

The most obvious change has been the redefinition of political space in Arab societies. This has been shown again and again in the years since 2011, from the recent protests in Lebanon and Iraq, to the Hirak movement in Algeria.

Across North Africa and the Middle East, protests and demonstrations of public anger are no longer simply seen as signs of a challenge toward authorities, but rather as the potential forewarning of an uprising, or even a revolution.

Each social crisis opens the floodgates for real and uninhibited challenges to the regimes in power. Even Egypt, which in 2013 saw a return to authoritarianism that would make previous regimes in other Arab countries pale in comparison, is not exempt. Activists and groups have learned how to speak out against the government, often at great personal risk. A majority of citizens are now reasoning based on the hypothesis that the players currently holding power can be removed.

Secularism v religion

Across the region, the social and political spheres have become more secular, as both a cause and a consequence of the Arab Spring. The push for democratisation both fed into and was fed by the belief in egalitarian citizenship. Regimes, feeling challenged, encouraged sectarian attitudes and divisions, hoping to transform a vertical conflict (between society and authority) into a series of horizontal disputes (Sunnites against Shiites, Muslims against Copts, Arabs against Kurds, and so on).

In other words, by changing the original narrative, which was mainly secular and drew on political and social progress as a foundation, certain regimes placed their survival above that of their country’s unity. Syria is a textbook example of this.

While a number of religious groups, Islamists among them, took the side of popular uprisings during the Arab Spring, it is nevertheless difficult to give a definitive judgement on the role of specific religious groups, both at the time and since. It would be hard to compare Tunisia’s Ennahda, for example, with Hamas in the Palestinian Territories, or the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt, given how widely communication, strategies, and even long-term goals vary from one group to another.

This is partly because the Arab Spring uprisings were not religious by nature; they were never built on the necessity of defending religious traditions, and even less so a threatened Muslim identity. Nor was the Islamist narrative the engine for these changes. Religious figures and movements jumped on the bandwagon, but they never managed to control the direction of these wide-reaching movements.

However, in burgeoning democracies, starting with Tunisia, the power distribution phase gave way to other laws, specifically those regarding the ability to siphon off votes. Islamist groups were clearly masters of this game, boosted by their claimed capital of moral and political purity and long-established abilities to mobilise people.

And so over the past ten years we have seen the subject of religion take centre stage, as social revolutions, in becoming constitutional and partisan, had a duty to tackle the question at the same time as Islamist parties were integrating themselves into national political scenes in transition. Right now, the key takeaway is undeniably the rupturing of the Islamist landscape.

The rise of jihadism

Though jihadism has been an important part of the political and religious landscape in Arab countries and elsewhere for several decades, this phenomenon was indirectly strengthened by the uprisings in the early 2010s.

The rise of jihadism over the past ten years is connected to the fact that parts of these societies, particularly the youth, saw the Arab Spring uprisings from two related perspectives. On one hand, it was clear that the revolutions were not going to bear fruit immediately. On the other, they were no longer exclusively rooted in the present time and in their country’s society as it had always been. Another utopia existed, and jihadism competed with that promised by revolution.

As a result, certain countries such as Syria, which is still gripped by civil war and a serious sovereignty crisis, became echo chambers for Arab tensions, or even laboratories for new kinds of violent, radical movements to spread, as illustrated by Islamic State’s caliphate in Syria and Iraq.

The undeniable politico-religious violence that has arisen since 2011, driven by jihadi movements, is also social and generational. Jihadism attests to the fact that the political realities in the regions are currently at an unprecedented crossroads, between the shift away from traditional religion, the plight of governments, and the many social, economic and psychological tensions weighing on entire populations desperate to see their hopes come to pass.

This article is published as part of IPEV Live: Transition from Violence, Lessons from the MENA, a series of eight live conversations held every Tuesday from May 18 to June 29, 2021.

If so, you’ll be interested in our free daily newsletter. It’s filled with the insights of academic experts, written so that everyone can understand what’s going on in the world. With the latest scientific discoveries, thoughtful analysis on political issues and research-based life tips, each email is filled with articles that will inform you and often intrigue you.

Editor and General Manager

Find peace of mind, and the facts, with experts. Add evidence-based articles to your news digest. No uninformed commentariat. Just experts. 90,000 of them have written for us. They trust us. Give it a go.

If you found the article you just read to be insightful, you’ll be interested in our free daily newsletter. It’s filled with the insights of academic experts, written so that everyone can understand what’s going on in the world. Each newsletter has articles that will inform and intrigue you.

In late 2010 and early 2011, a wave of pro-democracy uprisings and protests called the 'Arab Spring' or its Arabic term, al-Rabi’ al-‘Arabi, spread through the Middle East and North Africa (MENA).

It challenged the long-established authoritarian regimes in the region, specifically in Yemen, Tunisia, Libya, Egypt, Syria, and Bahrain. The Arab Spring triggered a political upheaval that swept across West Asia in 2011 and brought about an economic renewal in the region.

In December 2010, the uprising of anti-government protests started in Tunisia and gradually spread from country to country in revolts against long-time authoritarian rulers. Arab Spring — a wave of uprisings, revolts, protests, and unrest, spread across Arabic nations in the Middle East and North Africa by early 2011.

Pro-democratic protests, which escalated rapidly due to the internet penetration, ended up overthrowing the governments of Tunisia, Libya, Egypt, and Yemen.

Many reasons such as economic, political, and social were a few major factors leading to the episode of Arab Spring. The aim of the rise of the movement was to protest against unfair governmental rule and demand to reinstate fundamental rights of the people.

More than just removing autocrats, the uprisings were primarily about a massive demand by the public for better economies and governance, rule of law, equal rights and, most of all, a voice in how their countries should run. So far, millions have lost their homes in war across Syria, Yemen and Iraq and struggle to find livelihoods, educate their children and feed themselves.

By 2013, rulers were removed from power in Tunisia, Egypt, Libya, and Yemen, civil uprisings erupted in Bahrain and Syria, major protests broke out in Algeria, Morocco, Iraq, Kuwait, Jordan and Sudan and minor protests took place in Saudi Arabia, Mauritania, Djibouti, Oman, Western Sahara, and Palestinian territories.

Between 2013 and 2018, the scale of protest in the MENA region decreased significantly, a period referred to as the 'Arab Winter'.

By early 2018, a new wave of protest swept through the countries including Tunisia, Jordan, Egypt, Iraq, Iran and Lebanon. Protests in Sudan led to military coup defeat, ousting former president Omar al-Bashir. Over the years, the protests culminated in sustained campaigns involving demonstrations, strikes, rallies and marches as well as the productive utilisation of social media to communicate, organise, and raise awareness about Internet censorship and tyranny.

What gave birth to the Arab Spring?

In December 2010, a Tunisian street vendor Mohammed Bouazizi set himself ablaze in the city of Sidi Bouzid to protest the draconian seizing of his vegetable shop by the police over failure to receive a permit. His sacrifice became a catalyst for the Arab Spring revolution in Tunisia. The pro-democracy protests that ensued in Tunis, eventually provoked authoritarian president Zine El Abidine Ben Ali, who ruled for more than 23 years, to resign and flee to Saudi Arabia.

The regime change in Tunisia inspired activists in other countries and began to protest authoritarian governments in their own nations. The street protests triggered a wave of revolts across the Middle East as people began to voice their angst against unemployment, corruption, discrimination, authoritarianism, and poverty.

Impact of Arab Spring

The Arab Spring caused the end of many long-standing autocrats. However, in the ten years that have passed, the legacy of the movement seems 'mixed'. In fact, only Tunisia is working towards attaining democracy despite the high rate of unemployment. On the other hand, Syria, Yemen and Libya are in the grip of civil wars and Egypt, in particular, has reverted to an autocratic regime and has clamped down on free speech and journalistic freedoms with little or no protest from Western governments.

Civil society activists still battling oppression and corruption across the Middle East. The 2011 uprisings reflected that the people of the Middle East and North Africa want freedom and equality.